| 2000 - 2001 Season |
| June Stacy -- Best Actress (Come Back, Little Sheba) Dave Bloom -- Best Actor (The Mousetrap) Ann Munch -- Best Supporting Actress (Social Security) Joe Narsavage -- Best Supporting Actor (The Foreigner) Chris Yaxley -- Best Character Actress (Come Back, Little Sheba) Joel Munch -- Best Character Actor (Social Security) Adelaide White -- Best Debut Actress (The Mousetrap) Joe Carvajal -- Director, Best Play of Season (The Mousetrap) Rice's Furniture Company -- Special Appreciation Award BLT YOUTH TROUPE AWARDS (All for work in The Enchanted Flute) Scarlett Royal -- Best Actress Zac Thompson -- Best Actor Elsa and Ingrid Allstaedt -- Best Female Vocalists Avery McGaha -- Best Male Vocalist Logan Crane and Tessa Dodson -- Tenacity Awards Christan Raxter -- The Beulah Zachary Award |
| Christan Raxter Beulah Zachary Award Winner |
| Dave Bloom |

| Joe Narsavage |
| Scarlett Royal |
| Zac Thompson |
| 2001 - 2002 Season |
| Kathleen Moore |

| Gene O'Hare |
| June Stacy |

| Nedra Carvajal |







| 2002 - 2003 Season |
| Kristina Todd -- Best Actress (The Fantasticks) Sy Berg -- Best Actor (The Price) Adelaide White -- Best Supporting Actress (The Price) Bob Stacy -- Best Supporting Actor (The Price) Terri Owen -- Best Character Actress (Last of the Red Hot Lovers) Sy Berg -- Best Character Actor (The Price) Celeste Thorington -- Best Debut Actress (Last of the Red Hot Lovers) Bob Singdahlsen -- Best Debut Actor (Theft) Kathleen Moore -- Director, Best Play of Season (The Price) Alan Edick -- Director, People's Choice Award (The Fantasticks) Tonny & Ireene van der Leeden -- President's Award |
| Kristina Todd |
| Terri Owen |
| Adelaide White |
| Celeste Thorington |

| Bob Singdahlsen |


| Bob Stacy |
| Sy Berg |


| Frank Batchelor |
| Chris Yaxley |

| Joel Munch |

| Joe Carvajal |

| Al Edick |
| Norman Bossert |



