| 1995 - 1996 Season |
| 1996 - 1997 Season |
| 1997 - 1998 Season |
| 1998 - 1999 Season |
| 1999 - 2000 Season |
| Jennifer Newell -- Best Actress (Bus Stop) Joe Carvajal -- Best Actor (Angel Street) Joe Potts -- Best Supporting Actor (Rockers) Dede Hunter -- Best Supporting Actress (More Than Meets The Eye) Sherri Cafaro -- Best Debut Actress (Angel Street) Paul Williams -- Best Debut Actor (Bus Stop) Patricia White, Ireene van der Leeden, Diane Williams -- Best Ensemble Actresses (Rockers) Barbara Rinc -- Outstanding Service Award Dottie Vaniman -- Special Service Award 50th ANNIVERSARY CELEBRATION Sam Cope -- Special Service Award ("50 Years Of BLT") Hugo Martin -- Special Service Award ("50 Years Of BLT") BLT YOUTH TROUPE AWARDS (All for The Enchantment, written and directed by Sonia Arnold): Elsa Allstaedt -- Best Actress Ben Talcott -- Best Actor Erin Wood -- Best Vocalist Christan Raxter -- Outstanding Original Musical Score Keegan Fraker -- Best Supporting Actor |

| Shirley Harper -- Best Actress (Play On) Joe Carvajal -- Best Actor (Dangerous Corner) Nan Margaret Ruesch -- Best Supporting Actress (Dangerous Corner) Stephen Jackson -- Best Supporting Actor (Allocating Annie) Joel Jensen -- Best Debut Actor (Play On) Jennifer Salkewicz -- Best Debut Actress (Allocating Annie) Dave Bloom -- Best Character Actor (Dangerous Corner) Irma Holcombe -- Best Character Actress (Play On) Mary Ann Schmitt -- Most Humorous Character, Female Role (Dearly Departed) Joel Munch -- Most Humorous Character, Male Role (Dearly Departed) Susan Fosmire -- "Break A Leg" Award (Dangerous Corner) Donna Kaup, Jay White, Joe Carvajal, Sonia Arnold and Patricia White -- BLT Service Awards |

| Mary Ann Schmitt |

| Stephen Jackson |
| Maxwell Bernson -- Best Actor (On Borrowed Time) Kristin Hall -- Best Actress (On Borrowed Time) Susan Fosmire -- Best Supporting Actress (Don't Dress For Dinner) Dick Thompson -- Best Supporting Actor (Don't Dress For Dinner) June Stacy -- Best Character Actress (On Borrowed Time) Roger Casler -- Best Character Actor (On Borrowed Time) Tammy Hopkins -- Most Humorous Actress (Don't Dress For Dinner) Joel Jensen -- Most Humorous Actor (Don't Dress For Dinner) Joyce Jaffe -- Best Debut Actress (The Cemetery Club) John Snow -- Best Debut Actor (A Murder Is Announced) Hannah Locke -- Most Promising Young Actress (On Borrowed Time) Joe Potts -- Director, Best Comedy of Season (Don't Dress For Dinner) Dave Bloom -- Director, Best Drama of Season (On Borrowed Time) |

| Jennifer Newell |
| Christan Raxter |

| Joel Munch |

| Max Bernson |
| Roger Casler |
| 1994 - 1995 Season |
| Dot Drew -- Best Actress (The Lion In Winter) Joe Carvajal -- Best Actor (Love, Sex And The I.R.S.) Patricia White -- Best Supporting Actress (Love, Sex And The I.R.S.) Jim Ware -- Best Supporting Actor (The Lion In Winter) Shirley Harper -- Best Character Actress (Love, Sex And The I.R.S.) Dave Bloom -- Best Character Actor (Love, Sex And The I.R.S.) Angie Fowler -- Best Character Actress (Quilters) Marti Jones & Mary Beth Shumate -- Best Debut Performances (Quilters) Tim Mandela -- Best Young Actor (The Lion In Winter) Elana Marshall -- Best Young Actress (Quilters) Deborah Hodges -- Best Actress in a Leading Role (Love Letters) John von Stein, III -- President's Award Ed Leddy -- Technical Award Jake & Kathy Nissley, Sonia Arnold, Oscar Reiner, Jeanette Austin and Jan Cox -- BLT Service Awards |
