| 1983 - 1984 Season |
| Best Actress: Wendy Alderman (Any Wednesday) Best Actor: Jim Keeley (Morning's At Seven) Best Supporting Actress: Judy D'Arville (Any Wednesday) Best Supporting Actor: Hugo Martin (Morning's At Seven) Best Debut Actress: Ruth Reed (The Glass Menagerie) Best Debut Actor: George Perkins (The Glass Menagerie) Best Play: "Any Wednesday" (Nadine Huters, Director) Service Award: Cheryl Walkup Technical Award: Robert and Sue Cilley |
| 1984 - 1985 Season |
| Best Actress: Pegge Strandbergh (The Girls In 509) Best Actor: John Von Stein (The Good Doctor) Best Supporting Actress: Ruth Reed (The Good Doctor) Best Supporting Actor: David Holcombe (The Girls In 509) Best Debut Actress: Edith Hook (Night Watch) Best Debut Actor: Tom Bindrim (Night Watch) Best Character Actress: Pat McDermott (The Good Doctor) Best Character Actor: John Hernandez (The Good Doctor) Service Award: Keith Stevens Technical Award: Shirley Merrell |
| 1985 - 1986 Season |
| 1986 - 1987 Season |
| 1987 - 1988 Season |
| Best Actress: Wendy Alderman (Crimes Of The Heart) Best Actor: John Hernandez (Unhealthy To Be Unfriendly) Best Supporting Actress: Julie Chostiner (Crimes Of The Heart) Best Supporting Actor: Ted von Allworden (UTBU) Best Debut Actress: Babe McGrath (Crimes Of The Heart) Best Debut Actor: Kevin Brinkley (Catch Me If You Can) Best Character Actress: Cheryl Walkup (UTBU) Best Character Actor: John Hernandez (Catch Me If You Can) Service Award: Hugo Martin Technical Award: Joe Potts Beulah Zachary Award: Sue Cilley |
| 1988 - 1989 Season |
| Best Actress: Dodie Jerz (A Bad Year For Tomatoes) Best Actor: John Hernandez (The Very Great Grandson Of Sherlock Holmes) Best Supporting Actress: Helen Graham Best Supporting Actor: Jim Keeley (The Very Great Grandson Of Sherlock Holmes) Best Debut Actor: Gary Gardin Best Character Actress: Jennie Latimer (Lo And Behold) Best Character Actor: Tom Bindrim (Lo And Behold) Service Award: Jake Nissley Technical Award: John Daugherty Beulah Zachary Award: Sue Cilley |
| 1989 - 1990 Season |
| 1990 - 1991 Season |
| Best Actress: Carolyn Schroeder (Funny Valentines) Best Actor: Blaque Fowler (The Business Of Murder) Best Supporting Actress: Jennie Latimer (The Business Of Murder) Best Supporting Actor: Val Palmer (The Business Of Murder) Best Debut Actor: Joe Carvajal (Mr. Angel) Best Character Actress: Vicki Johnson Hickman (Funny Valentines) Best Character Actress (tie): Patricia DePra (Mr. Angel) Service Award: Ted von Allworden Technical Award: Robert Cilley Youth Acting Awards: Brittany Whitmire and Zahra Loke (Mr. Angel) |
| Joe Carvajal |
| John Hernandez |
| Pegge Strandbergh |
| Jim Keeley |
| Jennie Latimer |
| 1992 - 1993 Season |
| Best Actress: Patricia White (Exit The Body) Best Actor: Joe Carvajal (The Night Of January 16th) Best Actress in a Major Role: Diane Plott (The Night of January 16th) Best Character Actor: Gene O'Hare (A Thurber Carnival) Best Character Actress: Helen Graham (A Thurber Carnival) Best Debut Actress: Jill Lusby (The Night of January 16th) Best Debut Actor: Ed Nicholson (The Night of January 16) Other BLT Award Winners: Ted & Wanda von Allworden, Rick Jennings, Jeanette Austin |
| Best Actress: Pegge Strandbergh (40 Carats) Best Debut Actress: Patricia White (40 Carats) (no other data found....) |
| Best Actress: Patricia White (The Best Of Friends) No other data found.... |
| Patricia White |
| 1993 - 1994 Season |
| Gene O'Hare |
| (No data found....) |
| 1991 - 1992 Season |
| Best Actress: Cheryl Walkup (Steel Magnolias) No other data found.... |
| Cheryl Walkup |