| 1974 - 1975 Season |
| Best Actor: Bill Bush Best Actress: Berry Pidgeon Best Supporting Actor: Mike Vaniman Best Supporting Actress: Tia Landon Best Debut Actor: John Sinclair Best Character Actor: Lois Lambing Best Youth Actor: Doug Norton President's Award: Tia Landon Service Award: Agnes Wilson Technical Award for Set Design: Jim Dexter |
| 1975 - 1976 Season |
| Best Actress: Pat Fuleihan Best Actor: Jim Keeley Best Debut Performance: David Holcombe Best Character Actress: Jackie Richards Best Character Actor: Charlie Hines Best Youth Actress: Barbara Caldwell Beulah Zachary Award: Nadine Huters Best Summer Production: Mike Vaniman |
| 1976 - 1977 Season |
| Pat Fuleihan |
| 1977 - 1978 Season |
| 1978 - 1979 Season |
| 1979 - 1980 Season |
| Best Actor: Ron Daniels Best Actress: Judy D'Arville Best Supporting Actor: John von Stein Best Character Actress: Debra Shilling Best Debut Performance: Will Irby Beulah Zachary Award: Pat Fuleihan Service Award: Shirley Minell Service Award: Alice Roye Technical Award: Ken Rivenbak |
| Best Actress: Debra Shilling Best Actor: David Holcombe Best Supporting Actress: Judy D'Arville Best Supporting Actor: Jim Alderman Best Character Actor: Hugh Erikson Best Debut Performance: Bill Wilson President's Award: Paula Benton Best Play (The Man Who Came To Dinner): Nadine Huters, Director |
| Best Actor: Jim Alderman Best Actress: Wendy Alderman Best Supporting Actor: John von Stein Best Character Actor: Robert Cilley Best Character Actress: Judy D'Arville Best Debut Performance: Ed Miller Beulah Zachary Award: Jim Keeley Service Award: Debra Shilling Technical Award: Shirley Murvell |
| Robert Cilley |
| 1980 - 1981 Season |
| 1981 - 1982 Season |
| David Holcombe |
| Best Actor: David Holcombe (Life With Father) Best Actress: Liz Yehling (Lilies Of The Field) Best Supporting Actor: Mark Alvin (Lilies Of The Field) Best Supporting Actress: Melanie Mather (Life With Father) Best Character Actor: Paul Welch, III (Lilies Of The Field) Best Debut Actor: Marion Boatwright (Lilies Of The Field) Best Play: "Lilies Of The Field" (Nadine Huters, Director) Service Award: Cynthia Brummett Technical Award: Sue Cilley Youth Award: Neil Warren (Life With Father) |
| 1982 - 1983 Season |
| Best Actress: Pegge Strandbergh (Harvey) Best Actor: Joe Potts (Fools) Best Supporting Actor: John Von Stein (Fools) Best Supporting Actress: Louisa Cartledge (Fools) Best Character Actress: Sue Cilley (The Mousetrap) Best Debut Actor: Bill Jones (The Mousetrap) Best Debut Actress: Connie Cope (Fools) Technical Award: Robert Cilley Service Award: David Holcombe |
| Sue Cilley |
| Joe Potts |
| Looking for data.... |
| Looking for data.... |