| 1967 - 1968 Season |
| 1968 - 1969 Season |
| Best Actress: Ann Godey Best Actor: John Setzer Best Supporting Actress: Jean Dixon Best Supporting Actor: John Wells Beulah Zachary Award: Maud Freeman Special Service Award: Jeanne Mueller Lighting Award: Anthony Pidgeon |
| 1969 - 1970 Season |
| Best Actor: Jim Keeley Best Actress: JoAnn Dehon Best Supporting Actor: Don Davies Beulah Zachary Award: Jim Nickles Special Service Award: Martha & Jim Murphy Special Service Award: Walt Rogers Special Youth Award: Chris Pidgeon Technical Award: Don Pidgeon |
| Best Actor: Bill Norris (Born Yesterday) Best Actress: Dottie Vaniman (The Little Foxes) Best Supporting Actor: Ed Keith (The Little Foxes) Best Supporting Actress: Mary Kilgore (The Little Foxes) Beulah Zachary Award: Jeanette Austin Technical Award (Set Design): Hilde Kilmek |
| Jim Keeley |
| 1970 - 1971 Season |
| Best Actress: Maggie Masters Best Actor: John Wells Best Supporting Actress: Freddie Norris Best Supporting Actor: Carle Wilson Best Character Actress: Jeanette Austin Best Debut Performance: Jim Thomas Beulah Zachary Award: Mike & Dottie Vaniman Special Service Award: Gus Masters Special Youth Awards: Paul Duvall & Butch Hunter |
| 1971 - 1972 Season |
| Best Actor: Hugo Martin Best Actresses: JoAnn Dehon & Jeanette Austin Best Supporting Actor: Jim Keeley Best Supporting Actress: Dottie Tinsley Best Juvenile Actor: John Pidgeon Beulah Zachary Award: Ed Freeman Special Service Awards: Margaret & John Wells Lighting Award: Tom Cox Props Award: Joy Zachary |
| 1972 - 1973 Season |
| Best Actress: Linda Gash Best Supporting Actress: Pat Fuleihan Best Supporting Actor: Tom Barclay Best Character Actor: Hall Parrish Best Debut Performance: Virginia Phillips Youth Acting Award: Cathy Collins President's Award: Aileen Hanley Special Service Award: Berry Pidgeon Technical Award for Set Design & Construction: Walter Davis Children's Award: Robbie Pidgeon |
| 1973 - 1974 Season |
| Best Actor: Bill Norris Best Actress: Pat Fuleihan Best Supporting Actor: Hall Parrish Best Supporting Actress: Wendy Alderman Best Debut Performance: Nadine Huters Youth Acting Award: Karen Southerland President's Award: Helen Hawthorne Service Award: Carle Wilson Technical Award: Jim Alderman |
| Carle Wilson |
| Hugo Martin |

| Dottie Vaniman |

| Hall Parrish |